Why the demo always works, and how to run one that tells the truth
Every robot demo succeeds. The parts are perfect, the lighting is good, the speed is set a little low, and the one part that always jams was left in the truck. Here is why that is not dishonest, exactly, and how to run a demo that tells you what the cell will do at four in the afternoon on your floor with your parts.
The short answer
A demonstration is designed to show that a thing is possible, and it does that honestly. What it cannot do, by construction, is show what happens when the thing is ordinary: a part slightly wrong, a tote slightly overfull, a line running at the rate it hits on Thursday rather than the rate on the brochure. Westworld worked beautifully until the guests arrived. The cure is not to distrust demos. It is to bring the guests.
Why it always works
The vendor picked the parts, and they are the good ones, clean, consistent and presented the way the gripper likes. The lighting is the vendor's, which matters enormously to a vision system and not at all to the buyer until it does. The speed is set where the cell looks smooth, which is usually below where it would have to run to hit your peak. The operator is the person who built the cell and knows which way the part wants to be nudged. And the one part that always jams, the one every line has, was not invited. None of this is fraud. It is what a demo is for. But it is not a prediction.
The six things to bring
Your worst three parts. The lightest, the heaviest, and the one that is always slightly wrong: the vented carton, the bent bracket, the casting with the burr. If the gripper handles those, it handles your average. If the vendor only wants to see your average, you have learned something about the vendor.
Your real containers. Parts in the bin they actually arrive in, not on a tray the vendor supplied. Part presentation is half of every project, and the demo tray hides it.
Your peak rate, measured. Ask for the cell to run at the rate your line hits on its busiest hour, not the average, and watch whether it keeps up with margin. If the answer is that the cell can run faster but is set lower for the demo, ask to see it faster.
Your lighting, or a photo of it. A vision system that finds the part under studio lights may not find it under high bay sodium with a skylight. Ask what the camera needs and whether your room has it.
A stopwatch. Time a full cycle from pick to pick, including the gripper opening and closing, the settle before release, and any wait. Compare it to the number on the datasheet and to your takt. The gap between the three is your education.
Someone from your floor. The operator who will own the cell should run the demo for ten minutes with the vendor's hands behind their back. If it takes an engineer to keep it running, you will need an engineer to keep it running.
The questions to ask while it runs
What happens when a part is upside down? Make one upside down and find out. What happens at a tool change, a pallet swap, a reel change? Do it. How does the cell recover from a stop: from the top, or from where it was? Who would do that recovery on your floor at two in the morning? And the question that separates the serious vendors from the rest: show me one it dropped.
What a good vendor does
Welcomes all of this. A good integrator would rather lose the sale on the demo floor than lose the account on your floor, and will often ask for your worst parts before you think to bring them. The casebook on this site is full of cells that work because someone asked the hard question early: the Danish greenhouse that trialed its real herbs in the gripper, the molder whose mobile cobot only worked because a mating plate held it to half a millimeter. The question is cheap. The answer is a project.
The holodeck problem
Star Trek's holodeck could simulate anything except the one thing that mattered, which was what would happen when the safety protocols were off. A demo with the vendor's parts and the vendor's hands has the safety protocols on. Your plant does not. Run the demo with them off, in the sense that counts: your parts, your rate, your people, your light.
If you want a list of what to bring for your specific application, describe the station to Joe, the concierge on this site. He will tell you which three parts to put in the box and which question will make the room go quiet.
Related on this site
- Ten questions that make a robot salesperson sweat
- A model number is not a specification
- Size for peak, not average
- Grippers, explained with a kitchen drawer
- What happens the day the robot arrives
A demo is a cell in its Sunday clothes. Bring your worst three parts, your real containers, your peak rate and your lighting, and watch what happens when the vendor is not driving.
Put it to the test on your own job
Tell Joe what you are running and he will apply this to your numbers, including telling you when a robot is the wrong answer.
More notes